Book Review: Alanna: The First Adventure
This year is turning out to be a big year for rereading old favorites from my childhood. Today's book is Alanna: The First Adventure by Tamora Pierce, and I finished it last night well after bedtime. It's short, as most YA books of that era were (though this was mostly before the invention of the YA marketing genre), about a girl who switches places with her twin brother in order to train to become a knight. It was originally published in 1983, and is part of a swath of fantasy books aimed at girls that were all about not fitting into the "useless lady" stereotype. Other stories in this vein are Dealing with Dragons by Patricia C. Wrede (1990) and The Hero and the Crown by Robin McKinley (1984).
I remember reading and loving this book. I don't remember when I first read it, but it was somewhere between 2002 and 2005. According to my records (before 2015) I've read it four other times, which was surprising to me because I don't normally call myself a rereader.
The story is quite fast paced, speeding through more than two years of Alanna's page training. The fast pace makes for a quick read, and is good for the target age (the main character starts the book ten or eleven years old, so the target age is around that), but I think all the modern YA fantasy I have read has spoiled me for more things happening in a tighter time frame. It also feels a little dated now, because it is more common to see YA fantasy on the other side of the "girls have to prove themselves to join the boys club" hill.
The biggest thing I noticed, being so much older with lots of writing experience under my belt, is how bare the setting descriptions were. There were many places where the setting wasn't described at all. In workshops, I would have marked that as "white room syndrome" and told the writer to fix it. But here, in a published and beloved novel, this "problem" is all over the place. It makes me wonder if perhaps modern writing spends too much time on setting descriptions rather than focusing on moving the story forward. I'm reading a middle grade series with books that are three to four times as long as this one, and I'm always wondering "why is this so long?" Perhaps it's because every setting is described in too much detail.
The one downside to reading this book is I don't own any of the others, for some strange reason, so I can't immediately jump into the next one.
Overall, 4 out of 5 stars.
Thoughts to share? I have a contact page now!