Book Review: When Among Crows
When Among Crows by Veronica Roth is a novella at 163 pages. I read it on recommendation from someone in my online writing group (and because I really like Roth's writing). I'm torn on this one. The writing itself was great, and while I had meant to take three days1 to read it I ended up finishing it in one day. The story was also well paced, with quiet moments in between scenes of oftentimes gruesome violence (including self-inflicted), and well-placed reveals that slowly unraveled the history of the main character and the truth of what he was trying accomplish.
But for such a short novel, it felt odd to me that there were three different points of view, and I got the feeling that the only reason for the changes was to conceal from the reader the main character's true motivation until the final act. I can't say it didn't work, but I can't decide if I didn't like it or not, because it wasn't subtle, and I don't like things being concealed from me just for a big reveal later.
Then there was one character at the end who was supposed to be a super powerful witch. The way she was talked about leading up to her appearance on the page, I was reminded of the Luidaeg from the October Daye series. Except when she was on the page, she didn't feel on that level, and it left me disappointed because the Luidaeg is one of my favorite side characters ever written.
There were also a couple of spots where certain... philosophies were present that pulled me out of the story because they clashed with my own view of the world. A specific example: near the beginning, the main character is talking with a woman, trying to get information to find someone related to his goal, and they have an exchange where he asks how he can prove he doesn't intend to harm her or the person he's looking for, and she says the following: "All men mean harm. The question is simply when" (Roth, 24). And as a woman with four brothers who are all wonderful men, this idea (in fiction and in reality) pisses me off. I understand what it's doing for this character specifically, but it still pulled me right out of the story and almost made me quit.
Finally, the idea of holy knights that kill monsters being the evil bad guys also had me of two minds because 1) in a world where monsters do exist and do actively feed on negative human emotion, giving them strong incentive to incite those emotions, the people that fight back against that darkness should not be the bad guys but 2) the fact that these knights use dark blood magic to accomplish their goals, fighting the darkness with more darkness does feel evil, and then 3) this is pretty much the same framing of the antagonists in the novel I wrote for my master's thesis, so I can't really say much.
My thoughts about this novella sure are complicated, for something so short.
In the end, I have to give it 3 out of 5 stars, and I don't think I will pick up the sequel.
Thoughts to share? I have a contact page now!
I have a research project I've started, with a handful of books I need to get through, so I put together a reading schedule similar to what I did when I was in college, breaking the reading down in a pages/day way.↩