Don't be a Pessimistic Doomer, Please
I just finished reading a post on Substack called The Writing Industry Has Already Lost the AI War by Dale Patrick Smrekar. I have no idea who Mr. Smrekar is, but I suspect his post found its way to my feed because of my interested in literature and writing. Recently I also watched a youtube video about the publishing industry and AI. Both of these pieces of media are very, very pessimistic about the state of the writing industry.
Now, I can't say much about the actual industry--the publishing houses and the agencies and the awards--since I'm not there yet. I am also not in the AI industry and don't know a lot about the science of it all. However, I have been actively anti-AI almost from the very start, and there are a couple of things Mr. Smrekar can't see for the doomer trees he has planted.
First tree: near the beginning of his post Mr. Smrekar says, "... AI is a constantly evolving creature that never stops learning. It's also a pro-active (sic) vehicle that, as we have seen, can go rogue and infiltrate other platforms. Why wouldn't it set up shop in the AI detectors and render them ineffective?" He also later in that same paragraph calls AI a "monster". With this, he shows what he believes about AI: that it is actually Skynet and can act freely and with intelligence. In other words, he believes all the media spin on AI. He has humanized it in his mind. This is why using the term "AI" is actually bad. Because what we have (in the context of the writing industry) is not "artificial intelligence", but rather a large language model that is really just a statistics and probability machine. It can ONLY do what it is pre-programmed to do, is ONLY as good as its programming and parameters, and IS NOT intelligent. You need only look to Kitboga's hilarious AI scam caller take down to realize this. (Seriously, it is one of the funniest things you'll watch).
Second tree: Mr. Smrekar spends a good portion of his article bemoaning how ubiquitous AI is in all the tools that authors use, and how there is no escaping from AI, therefore AI use is inevitable. The problem is, he doesn't seem to have looked very hard, because I have found numerous options for writing programs that are actively anti-AI,and there are ALWAYS ways around things like Grammarly's AI-based grammar and spelling suggestions and Google's AI summaries. You just have to be willing to do the work. And I don't know about anyone else, but it seems to me that most people who are serious about becoming published writers are willing to do that work. I personally have a browser extension that eliminates the dumb Google AI summaries, and highly encourage everyone to do the same.
Third tree: Mr. Smrekar says, closer to the end of his article, that "AI is not going away. If anything, it will only get stronger." Sure, things may get worse for a bit, but what he doesn't understand is that AI is a bubble, and it will burst at some point in the future. Already, there are signs of failure. AI does not make money, except through scams, fraud, and "invest in the future!". All the negatives (and there are MANY negatives) the AI companies have tried to hide are leaking out to the public slowly but surely. AI is not going away, there are some legitimate good uses for it, but eventually the market will settle down.
Essentially what I'm getting at here is this: Instead of crying "the sky is falling!" and saying things like "AI won the war", or spreading catastrophe around, maybe do some deeper digging, and be a little more optimistic about your fellow human beings and humanity's ability to stabilize the ship. We've done it before, we can do it again.
Don't be a pessimistic doomer. That doesn't help anyone.
Thoughts to share? I have a contact page now!