Explicating Elle

Types of Fan Engagement

I am by no means an expert in fan expression. I've heard about people studying fan culture, all the way up to the doctorate level in college, which is cool, but not for me. There's a lot of hubbub around the internet right now because the biggest fanfiction repository, Archive Of Our Own (also known as AO3) is currently down for a while, because for a lot of people that is how they engage with their fandoms, how they spend their free time, and how they socialize. It's had me thinking a lot about how fans engage with their fandom, and how I have engaged with my favorite fandoms.

Fanfiction

Most people know about fanfiction. It's the most common type of fan engagement and the internet is full of it, both in big repositories like AO3 and fanfiction.net and in smaller, more specific places. Billions of words in every possible fandom have been written, from the shortest vignettes for 100 words to longfics in the hundreds of thousands of words or longer, on every topic from fixing canon to exploring what-ifs. Some pieces of fanfiction have even been turned into published fiction, going through a process of editing to "file the serial number off" and remove copyrighted material. Fanfiction is the big one.

I got my writing start in fanfiction. When I was eleven-ish I wrote Elfquest self-insert fanfiction in a composition notebook. When I was an older teenager I aggressively erased it all because I was embarrassed, and I regret that as an adult now. I also wrote tiny bits of Harry Potter fics (Harry has a twin named Harriet!), Stargate: Atlantis self-insert one shots, and Star Wars prequel stories (Anakin has a twin! Is there a pattern here??) before pivoting entirely to original fiction.

For a long time after that pivot, I steered clear of fanfiction. I briefly wrote a Valentine's Day one-shot for The Librarians when I was in my mid-twenties, but I was all in on my goal of publishing someday, and that meant working on original things. It's only been in the last few years that I've gotten back into writing fanfiction again, as a relief from the pressure of writing to publish (since that dream seems further and further away). I'm still just as bad at finishing fics as I am finishing my original work 😅.

A lot of my fanfiction ideas come from watching things and seeing bad writing (like with The White Olive Tree's horribly unsatisfying ending), or an opportunity to explore an alternate ending (like with The Librarians season four penultimate episode, and also the season four finale), or room to explore a philosophy through putting pressure on it (like the Jedi at the end of the Old Republic in Star Wars). The parentheticals are my four fanfiction projects, in various stages of completion, with the last two being my big longfics I'm trying to work on.

Fan Art

The other big form of fan engagement is through fan art. The internet is also full of fan art of people, places, and things within their favorite piece of media. Like fanfiction, there are many different kinds of fan art, from direct representation to alternate universe versions, and everything in between. And lots of porn, unfortunately (the same can be said about fanfiction, but it's easier to avoid in fanfiction).

I am not an artist, so I haven't created fan art, but I do enjoy a good piece of art every now and then. I think my favorite, though is a single issue fanzine (fan magazine) called Tea, Toast, and Ghosts, that I briefly helped make with other fans of Lockwood & Co that was created to be an in-universe magazine. It was beautifully done.

Fan Role-Play

Fan role-play is something I don't see as often anymore compared to when I was a teenager and internet forums were a big thing. At its most basic, fan role-play is all about inhabiting favorite characters and favorite worlds in a more interactive format than fanfiction or fan art, because you are not doing it by yourself, but with other fans. It's a bit like table-top role-play games (such as D&D) in that it is collaborative storytelling, but in text format on a forum where everyone is playing as a character from the IP they love.

This was the type of fan engagement I participated in the most. I joined considerably more fandoms in this way, because it felt like the barrier of entry was much lower than fanfiction (which required time and skill to write things). I haven't done this in a very long time, because internet forums went the way of the dodo bird (though I'm sure there are still groups who do this), but I still remember fondly participating in role-play sessions, imagining how my chosen character would interact with the situation they had found themselves in.

There are, of course, other ways to participate in fandom, from just watching or reading the property to buying every piece of merchandise available. But the three above are the big creative ways of participating.

Thoughts to share? I have a contact page now!

#blog